Can You Drink the Cup?

Mark 10:35-45

               ³⁵James and John, the sons of Zebedee, came forward to Jesus and said, “Teacher, we want you to do for us whatever we ask of you.” ³⁶And Jesus said to them, “What is it you want me to do for you?” ³⁷And they said, “Grant us to sit, one at your right hand and one at your left, in your glory.” ³⁸But Jesus said to them, “You do not know what you are asking. Are you able to drink the cup that I drink, or be baptized with the baptism that I am baptized with?” ³⁹They replied, “We are able.” Then Jesus said to them, “The cup that I drink you will drink; and with the baptism with which I am baptized, you will be baptized; ⁴⁰but to sit at my right hand or at my left is not mine to grant, but it is for those for whom it has been prepared.”

               ⁴¹When the ten heard this, they began to be angry with James and John. ⁴²So Jesus called them and said to them, “You know that among the Gentiles those whom they recognize as their rulers lord it over them, and their great ones are tyrants over them. ⁴³But it is not so among you; but whoever wishes to become great among you must be your servant, ⁴⁴and whoever wishes to be first among you must be servant of all. ⁴⁵For the Son of Man came not to be served but to serve, and to give his life a ransom for many.”

          Anybody have a file of all of the really stupid things you’ve said or done over the course of your lifetime?  Probably not a physical file—wouldn’t want anybody reading that!  But a file you keep in your brain.  And take out every so often to review, to remind yourself that “yeah, I really did say that.”  Kind of like you worry a sore tooth with your tongue.

          I find 3 am to be prime time for reviewing my Stupid Stuff File.  The dead of night always brings our misdeeds into sharp relief. 

          Now, the impulse to review these things isn’t necessarily a bad one.  We want to learn from the things we have done, in order to maybe do better the next time.  That’s a primary task of adulting—learning from mistakes and trying to be, you know, decent.

          Don’t you wonder if James and John, the Sons of Zebedee, and [play thunder noise] had a Stupid Stuff File?  If they did, I’m not sure there was a lot of reviewing and learning going on in the time that they were with Jesus.  They seem to move pretty seamlessly from being the ones who want to “call down fire” on inhospitable Samaritans to asking for the seats of honor next to Jesus in his glory, without much time for self-reflection.

          The Sons of Thunder.

          There’s no explanation for why Jesus named them Boanerges—the Sons of Thunder.

          And we don’t need one, do we?

          As you have probably figured out by now, I love the Sons of Thunder.  I love their thunder-y-ness.  I love their boldness.

          I love what they teach us, through what Jesus taught them.

          The lesson before us this morning is one of the best examples in the gospels of Jesus the Pedagogue.  Jesus at his professorial best.  Good teachers don’t just make good lesson plans—they are ready to turn any moment into a teachable moment.

          And luckily for Jesus, the disciples are pretty good at presenting opportunities for daily lessons on ethics and agriculture, fishing and forgiveness.

          James and John are among the best.  And this is their crowning achievement as unsuspecting object lessons.

          “Jesus,” they thunder, “We want you to do for us whatever we ask.”

          Oh, really?!  I’ve had a lot of teachers in my thirty years of schooling—I added it up—exactly thirty—I can tell you how 99% of them would respond to that opening salvo.

          But Jesus simply asks, “What is it you want?”

          “Grant us to sit, one at your right hand and one at your left, in your glory.”

          An impertinent request, yes?

          More than that, in fact.  They want the seats of glory, of honor.  They want the seat that belongs to God, in fact.  What is it we say about Jesus in the creed? 

On the third day he rose again,
ascended into heaven,
he is seated at the right hand of the Father.

          Jesus sits at the right hand of God, tradition holds, because the earliest scriptural record—from the Psalms on—teaches that the place of greatest honor is at God’s right hand. 

          So when they ask to sit at the right and left hand, they are asking to take a seat of honor, and a seat reserved for God (if Jesus is on the right—God is on the left).

          The one who sits at the right hand of God shares honor, and power, and authority, with God.

          This is not a small request.

          And the other disciples are not amused.

          “How dare they presume to have the seats of honor!  What jerks!”

          The other disciples are human. 

Jesus is human…and also God.  God’s incarnate one, come to be our object lesson in power, authority, and humility.

          Rather than joining the disciples in their anger and frustration, Jesus realizes that this is the moment to try once again to explain what this discipleship thing is all about.  How is God calling us to live together?

          So Jesus calmly turns to the Sons of Zebedee and says, “you think this is about power, right?”

          “Yeah, yeah yeah, Jesus!” they reply.  We wanna do the deeds of power like you do! 

          “Can you drink the cup I drink?  Can you be baptized with the baptism with which I am baptized?”

          “Yeah yeah yeah, Jesus!  Cup.  Baptism.  Check!”

          This has to be entry one in their Shared Stupid Stuff File.  Has to be.  Because, of course, they have no idea what they are saying.  It’s pretty clear to  us, looking back on it with our great 20/20 History Vision, that no one in this story understands what it means to drink the cup that Jesus will drink and to be baptized with the baptism with which he is baptized.

          No one truly understands it, and no one ever has.

          That’s why there was an Incarnation.  God became human because despite all the burning bushes and parted seas and prophetic words and deeds, people have persisted in struggling to understand how God has called us to live together.  We have been mired in the foggy vision of James and John forever.  Believing that what God wants is for us to be all-powerful, to have authority over others, so that we can bend them to our will.

          And we’ve used everything at our disposal, including the Christian faith, to try to get there.

          So God decided to just come down here.  To stand before us in the flesh, to look through our bluster and our naivete and our lust for power…and love us anyway.  Just as Jesus looked at James and John that day, when he said, “Yes, you can drink the cup.” And then turned calmly to the other disciples and explained about The Power.

          “The Power isn’t in lording it over each other.  It isn’t in having the seats of honor. 

          “The Power is Love, children.  Loving and serving each other.  Giving your life as a ransom for others.  The cup that I drink is a cup of suffering alongside those who suffer.

It is a cup of forgiveness.  A cup of joy born of true humility.

          It’s hard to imagine it from what we know, but history records that James and John did in fact drink that cup.  They became the bookends of the martyred apostles—witnesses to Jesus Christ from both sides of his passion.

          According to the Book of Acts, Chapter 12, James was so zealous in teaching the Way of Jesus that he was the first of the Apostles martyred by the Empire.

          John, his younger brother, was the only one of the disciples who did not die a martyr’s death.  History holds that he died of natural causes as late as 98 CE, after a long career of preaching Jesus Christ to thousands of new Christians.

          They could drink the cup.  They did drink the cup.  Jesus reminds us this morning that we are all able to drink the cup.

          James and John remind us that no matter who we are…no matter where we’ve been and what we’ve done…we can be witnesses to the Way of Jesus Christ.  No matter what’s in our Stupid Stuff File, we can be the ones who share a servant love with the world.  No matter what’s going on in the world—how coarse and unforgiving the rhetoric, how cruel and greedy the leadership—we can love and serve each other.  We can love and serve the world.

          Because we are loved.

          And we are forgiven.

          And Loved and Forgiven people have a power beyond any gold or silver or conquest.  We have the power of the cup, the power that lies within us at all times and can never be taken away.

          My prayer for you, people of God, is that you feel that power today.  You feel how much you are loved and how fully you’ve been forgiven by our God, and by our great teacher Jesus Christ.  I pray that being loved and forgiven helps you to unleash the power of love and forgiveness on a world that seems tilted another way. 

          We can tilt it back.  We can drink the cup.

Amen